Conversation of the new round of RF happening on time, but not sure about such an early launch of it.
Because in this matter, if this round will be happen in June, then next round will happen in November? Moving too fast, when RF pool is not refilling itself, since there is no new Haunts sales that would help it.
Idea of supporting Forge competitions sounds valid, but does it have much to do with RF?
Proposed % of rewards cut from originally rewarded categories sounds unfair.
If want to talk about fairness, then:
BRS category rewards is the most fat piece of the pie, let’s make the biggest cuts of rewards from there for Forge.
In case of Forge becoming a part of RF and it’s reward cuts let’s review it’s proposed changes in this matter:
To make it more fair, there is 4 different options of cuts, and the option to make Forge competition to be standalone.
Smithing competition and RF rewards deduction
- 3% BRS, 1 % XP and 1% Kin
- 2.5% BRS, 1.25% XP and 1.25% Kin
- 2.5% BRS, 1.5% XP and 1% Kin
- 2% BRS, 1.5% XP and 1.5% Kin
- Make Forge competition standalone (same as Alchemica Spending Competition)
In my opinion, if Forge competition is coming become a part of RF(when it reminds me more of Alchemica spending competition, which is not a part of RF) then, the numbers of changes with deductions above will be more fair, than:
Argument on reasonings, if Forge coming to RF:
Wearables burn for making another wearables = BRS curve stays the same or going up.
Wearable burn and wearable market have no bond with the BRS curve, it’s only making more deficit of wearables, not BRS itself. Simply, it’s just an overflow of one Rarity category of wearables to another.
P.S. I prefer if Forge will come up with the different proposal of making a competition of Blacksmith alone, as a season of smithing, without any negative effects on original rewards distribution of RF.
Because it sounds like forcing and raider seizure of rewards from RF, when:
Which is sounds like an transfusion of the original rewards of the RF pool to the special few:
To summarize - I’m Not against Forge competition, but it would be better to make it’s own pool of rewards, without RF integrations.
If there is any options for Forge to make such a pool on it’s own Smithing procesess and sales.
Also, 75000 GHST to reward people with Smithing, sounds like a giant cut of initial investment of Forge funding and it’s redemption of debt to the DAO will be almost = 0. Isn’t it too early to bring it on the table now? When DAO funding of Forge is still not yet fully covered with it’s paybacks + new funding round is coming up.